A database consisting of 163 data on the uranium content and U-234/U-238 initial activity ratio of 15 Italian travertine and calcareous tufa sites was created using data from the relevant literature. Using a graphical method, data were interpreted considering the U geochemistry in natural environments as well as the geological, hydrogeological and hydrogeochemical settings of each site. The U content and U-234/U-238 initial activity ratio in travertine and tufa appear to be affected by different factors, such as the availability of U in the aquifer rocks, the redox state of the waters, and the alpha-active radionuclide recoil phenomenon. The data allow the identification of four groups of travertines/tufas: (i) those precipitated from circulating groundwater, with a short/fast flow path, in volcanic rocks with a high radionuclide content; (ii) those precipitated from circulating groundwater, with a long, deep flow path in carbonate/evaporite formations with a relatively low radionuclide content; and (iii) those precipitated from cold waters associated with riverine systems, which are characterized by oxidizing conditions and fed by high-discharge springs recharged by carbonate aquifers. The fourth group represents the intermediate situations frequently occurring due to the mixing of waters from different aquifers. The results suggest an interpretative model that might contribute to the paleo-environmental reconstruction of fossil travertine and calcareous tufa depositing systems.